Sunday, July 17, 2016

Miguel de Quintana, 1720-1729

Miguel de Quintana begins retiring from public life and has his first conflicts with the man who replaces the chaplain killed on the Pedro Villasur expedition.

1720
Juan Mínguez doesn’t return from the Villasur campaign. His last signature in a San Ildefonso sacramental book was made in December 1719. [Archives]

1721
Carlos Delgado is in Santa Cruz for one month. Manuel de Sopeña is there for one month. José Antonio Guerrero is there for three. Angélico Chávez found no names after that until 1726. [Archives]

Josefa Sedano, sister of Antonia Sedano, sues Juan Lorenzo de Medina over a house in Santa Fé. [Twitchell]

1722
José de Quintana conveys land to Juan Lorenzo de Medina with the permission of Josefa Sedano. [Twitchell]

The issues in the case that involved Quintana’s brother aren’t obvious. None seem to have any ties with Miguel. [Comment]

Quintana witnesses a compromise over land boundaries between Miguel Martín and José de Atienza y Alcalá. [Twitchell]

May: Atienza begins notarizing diligencias matrimoniales for Santa Cruz. [Roots]

Atienza is Quintana’s brother-in-law. Assuming Quintana is developing symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis, or something similar, he may have trained Atienza. Since his handwriting, which was reproduced in the post for 26 June 2016, was still graceful and readable in 1732, one could assume it was his feet that first were affected, rather than his hands. Based on the age he gave in 1734, he would have been 44 years old. The disease later may have reached his ankles or knees, making it difficult to walk. [Comment]

1723
September: Quintana notarizes his last DM in Santa Cruz. Atienza continues as the notary. [Roots]

It isn’t clear if Quintana’s health makes if difficult for him to travel to notarize DMs, or if, after Sopeña becomes the local friar in 1724, he no longer is called by the church. [Comment]

1724
Sopeña is assigned to the mission at Santa Clara. He also serves the mission at Santa Cruz. Juan de Tagle still is available in the mission at San Ildefonso. [Archives]

1725
September: Quintana notarizes a DM for the marriage of Juan Antonio Martín and Feliciana Monroy. Antonio Martín, the boy’s father, had died in Chimayó. [Roots]

The wedding isn’t recorded in Santa Cruz, so it isn’t known if his sponsors were avoiding oversight by the friars in Santa Cruz, or if the family had some other reason for asking Quintana to be its notary. [Comment]

1726
January: Juan Sánchez de la Cruz is in the mission at Nambé until May 1727. He had been there in February of 1720 and from February 1722 until December 1728. [Archives]

At some time, Quintana hears Cruz preach at Nambé "about the punishments suffered by the damned in hell, and he felt his heart and spirit so distressed that it seemed to him - such was the terror that came over him - that he was going to be damned. But the thought came to him: ‘Miguel, neither you nor the holy father will be cast into hell,’ and the pleasure that this brought was so great that the tribulation left him." [Quintana 1734]

José Irigoyen later marks the passage above in single quotation marks, as heresy. [Lomelí]

February-August: Juan George del Pino appears in the mission at Santa Clara. [Archives]

At some time, Quintana gives Pino some verses on a sheet of paper. He uses the word versitos. [Quintana 1734]

Quintana has stopped writing coloquio celebrating Christ’s birth. A man asks him to write another. Quintana refuses at first, then agrees to do so. When he begins to write, he is seized with anguish. "I kept thinking it was all vanity and hypocrisy, and that I shouldn’t be getting mixed up in writing plays since I had had the experience of Your Paternal Grace telling me I was a hypocrite and that this was going to lead to my being publicly shamed by Your Paternal Grace himself." [Quintana 1732]

This is the first evidence that Sopeña has gone beyond advice in the confession to making public statements condemning Quintana. [Comment]

While Quintana is thinking of burning his work, he feels "a great help and a prodigious favor encouraging and strengthening me. It seems to take my hand and help me with these thought: ‘Don’t burn it, don’t burn it. Continue and offer your play to His Divine Majesty’." He uses the word coloquio throughout. [Quintana 1732]

Quintana indicates this is the event that converts his public writing into private dialogues between the character Miguel and God over contradictory demands made on Miguel by the Roman Catholic church. [Comment]

Psychologists might see this as a double bind of the kind that can lead to schizophrenic behavior. Quintana has avoided that outcome by utilizing the artistic form described in the post for 26 June 2016 that allows two sides to speak without an expectation of a dénouement. [Comment]

1727
Juan de Tagle makes his last entry in a San Ildefonso sacramental book in March. [Archives]

1728
José Bernardo Gómez begins notarizing DMs in Santa Cruz; Atienza continues signing them. [Roots]

Gómez is the son of Antonio Gómez Robledo, who was an illegitimate son of Francisco and a nephew of Andrés, the father-in-law of Ignacio Roybal. That makes him a cousin of Juan Gómez del Castillo, who will marry Quintana’s daughter Antonia. [Families, 19 June 2016]

Notes: Dates in brackets refer to earlier postings. Comments are those of the author.

Chávez, Angélico. Archives of the Archdiocese of Santa Fe, 1678-1900, 1957.

_____. New Mexico Roots, Ltd, 1982.

_____. Origins of New Mexico Families, 1992 revised edition.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006.

Quintana, Miguel de. Coloquio, 1732, Santa Cruz; in Lomelí.

_____. Interrogation by José Antonio Guerrero in the Inquisition office, Santa Fé, 8 November 1734; in Lomelí.

Twitchell, Ralph Emerson. Spanish Archives of New Mexico, volume 1, 1914.

Sunday, July 10, 2016

Miguel de Quintana, 1693-1719

Miguel de Quintana’s coloquios in which God gave personal counsel to a character named Miguel fall under the Roman Catholic church’s rubric of private revelation. There was nothing inherently heretical about such revelations, but they were extremely difficult to establish as valid.

Augustin Poulain said in 1912 that, before one could judge the legitimacy of such claims, one needed to know something about the person in order to establish "that neither the demon nor the ecstatic’s own ideas have interfered (at least on important points) with God's action."

More specifically, one needed to establish the individual’s mental capabilities, needed to know if the person had "made progress in holiness and especially in humility," and needed to know if he had been "subjected to heavy trials," since it was "almost impossible for extraordinary favours to be conferred without heavy crosses."

The Holy Office in Ciudad de México had a similar understanding of such revelations in 1734. When the tribunal sent the denunciations back to Santa Fé, Diego Mangado y Clavijo specifically asked about "Quintana’s life and habits, his abilities and talents."

That was the point when the Santa Fé Inquisition office deviated from standard legal procedures, as described by Charles Cutter. If you remember the case of Leonor Domínguez, described in March and April 2015 posts, the governor couldn’t accept her claims that she’d been bewitched by women at San Juan. His representative had to find evidence by interviewing other witnesses.

In the case of Quintana, the local commissary of the Holy Office, José Antonio Guerrero, only took evidence from the two men who already had denounced him. Neither gave any indication that Quintana was telling anyone, other than the friars, he was receiving heavenly inspirations. In the case of Francisco Gómez Robledo, discussed in entries posted between March 21 and March 28 of 2014, the necessity for secrecy did not stop the Inquisition from taking testimony from a number of individuals.

The carefully constructed historical record from the Inquisition archives in Ciudad de México thus provides little information on what was happening in Santa Cruz. What follows is an attempt to provide the missing details that lead to a climax in 1737.

1694 José Manuel Giltoméy, notarizes a diligencia matrimoniale in Santa Fé. [Roots]

1695
April: first surviving DM is done in Santa Cruz. Angélico Chávez didn’t identify the notary. [Roots]

1696
José Trujillo becomes alcalde in Santa Cruz. [1 February 2015]

November: Giltoméy notarizes a DM in Santa Cruz. He continues to sign ecclesiastical documents both there and in Santa Fé. He marries in Santa Cruz in 1697, and probably moves to Santa Fé sometime after. [Roots]

1701
Juan de Tagle is assigned to the mission at San Ildefonso. [Archives]

1704
October: Juan de Paz Bustillos notarizes one DM in Santa Cruz. Giltoméy continues as the church notary in Santa Fé. [Roots]

October: Quintana begins notarizing DMs in Santa Cruz. [Roots]

1710
June: Quintana is licenced as a scribe with the kingdom. The first document that survives with his notarization is from 1712. [Lomelí]

Juan Mínguez begins filling in at the mission at San Ildefonso. His name also begins appearing in Santa Clara and Santa Cruz sacramental books. [Archives]

At some time, Quintana gives Mínguez some verses on a sheet of paper. He uses the word versitos. [Quintana]

1712
July: an Apache ransomed by Tagle escapes on a horse owned by Quintana. He goes to the ranch of José Trujillo where he’s joined by two other Apaches. Andrés is a captive owned by Trujillo. Cristóbal had been a servant to Diego Martín and is now freed. One takes a horse belonging to Quintana that is kept there. [Lomelí]

August-October: after Andrés and Cristóbal return to Trujillo, Quintana sues Trujillo for the value of the two animals they didn’t bring back. He says "those two horses provided me some relief by carrying a few supplies and firewood and allowing me to run errands." Trujillo tells him to go recover them himself. [Lomelí]

I’ve found no hidden ties or animosities between the people whose names appear in this case. It’s a small community and people meet often. It may be like the dispute between José Antonio Naranjo and Diego de Torres described in the post for 28 February 2016, when the two men exaggerated their claims and left it to the judge to determine a just solution. [Comment]

The record found by Ralph Twitchell gives no outcome. [Twitchell v2]

1713
Juana de Carras, wife of José Velásquez, sues Antonia Sedano, wife of Juan Lorenzo de Medina, over land Micaela de Velasco, widow of Miguel García de la Riva, sold to Velásquez. Proceedings in Santa Fé. [Twitchell v1]

Jacinto Sánchez de Iñigo replaces José Trujillo as alcalde in Santa Cruz. [1 February 2015]

1719
In 1734, Manul de Sopeña says Quintana is remembered to have been throwing stones 15 years before. [Sopeña 1734]

Notes: Dates in brackets refer to earlier postings. Comments are those of the author.

Chávez, Angélico. Archives of the Archdiocese of Santa Fe, 1678-1900, 1957.

_____. New Mexico Roots, Ltd, 1982.

Cutter, Charles R. The Legal Culture of Northern New Spain, 1700-1810, 1995.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006.

Mangado y Clavijo, Diego. Instructions from the Inquisition to José Antonio Guerrero, 22 May 1734, Mexico City; in Lomelí.

Poulain, Augustin. "Private Revelations," The Catholic Encyclopedia, volume 13, 1912.

Quintana, Miguel de. Interrogation by José Antonio Guerrero in the Inquisition office, Santa Fé, 8 November 1734; in Lomelí.

Sopeña, Manuel de. Statement to José Antonio Guerrero in the Inquisition office, Santa Fé, 4 November 1734; in Lomelí.

Twitchell, Ralph Emerson. Spanish Archives of New Mexico, two volumes, 1914.

Sunday, July 03, 2016

Miguel de Quintana’s Health

Angélico Chávez noted Miguel de Quintana, in the coloquio he wrote in 1732 and 1737, avoided "anything that reminded him of sin and hell." He ascribed it to a conscience that had become abnormally fixated on its sins.

That comment made me realize that Quintana was more specific. His imagination was paralyzed by the contemplation of the "Sorrowful Mysteries," the ones today called The Agony in the Garden, The Scourging at the Pillar, The Crowning with Thorns, The Carrying of the Cross, and The Crucifixion. He stopped doing exercises suggested at meetings of the Third Order, which probably included beating himself.

I wondered if his problem wasn’t mental or spiritual as suggested by Chávez, but physical. In 1734, Manuel de Sopeña said Quintana "rarely goes to mass, giving as an excuse pain in the spleen." A few years later, Quintana wrote Juan Sánchez de la Cruz, "both of my bones are somewhat better."

Within his world of the four humors, the spleen was responsible for black bile. When the fluid sank into the joints it caused arthritis and rheumatism. The organ was associated with a melancholy temperament that, according to David Osborn, were associated with "dark, morose emotions."

Today, the terms arthritis and rheumatism are applied to any pain in the joints. Within the constellation of causes, rheumatoid arthritis is recognized as a degenerative disease that appears in middle age. It starts when part of the immune system turns on itself, and begins attacking the synovial fluid that lubricates joints. This leads to self-perpetuating chain of damage to bone cells followed by chemical overreactions that leads to more injury.

The inflammation or swelling of joints combined with reduced synovial fluid makes movement difficult. The emergency chemicals send messages through the nerves to the brain that register as pain. When the pain becomes chronic, the brain begins to direct avoidance behaviors that may exaggerate the effects of actions that cause pain. These stimuli are concrete and physical.

As mentioned in the post for 19 June 2016, Quintana was raised in Ciudad de México where masses were said by secular clergy. He probably didn’t confront the Franciscan emphasis on salvation through reenacting the agonies of Christ until he was in Santa Cruz. Their practices probably didn’t affect him until he was already in such pain he didn’t need reminders of it in sermons or in penances.

He told the local head of the Inquisition, José Antonio Guerrero, in 1734, that Cruz once "spoke about the punishments suffered by the damned in hell, and he felt his heart and spirit so distressed that it seemed to him - such was the terror that came over him - that he was going to be damned."

One suspects that whenever his pain was flaring, he became more afraid of exposing himself to additional reminders. He said the previous September "he was overcome with terror and great fear while coming to mass."

He added that, "If he starts praying the rosary, it happens that in the mysteries he loses his voice because of the pain, stays in a trance, and he remains alone in contemplation."

One rather assumes, when confronted with recollections of pain his mind simply shut down to protect itself from painful stimuli, whether visual, auditory, or physical. Such avoidance reactions can be counterproductive when they prevent people with joint problems from exercising them. They also can be hazardous when they cause people to withdraw from social activities in anticipation of harm.

Quintana himself may have recognized this danger. The mere existence of his interior dialogues suggested he had enough self-awareness to try to try to overcome his apprehensions. God constantly was admonishing, "Don’t be such a coward, Miguel."

He said that, even though he was afraid to go to that mass, "he felt other forces that urged him, saying ‘Hear mass! Hear mass!’ and he went to mass and felt an unsurpassable rejoicing in his soul."

Notes:
Chávez, Angélico. "The Mad Poet of Santa Cruz," New Mexico Folklore Record 3:10-17:1949.

Guerrero, José Antonio. Interrogation of Miguel de Quintana, 8 November 1734, Santa Fé; in Lomelí.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006; contains Spanish and English versions of all documents described here.

Osborn, David K. "Pathologies of Black Bile," Greek Medicine website.

Quintana, Miguel de. Coloquio, 1732, Santa Cruz, reprinted in Spanish and English by Lomelí.

Sopeña, Manuel de. Verification of previous statement to José Antonio Guerrero, 4 November 1734, Santa Fé; included in Lomelí.

Sunday, June 26, 2016

Miguel de Quintana’s Art

Miguel de Quintana had a trained aesthetic sensibility. If indeed he did attend the Cathedral School in Mexico City, he learned the common verse forms. His teachers may have been secular clergymen, perhaps ones trained by Jesuits.

He recalled he used to write "coloquio para festejar al Niño Dios en su nacimiento," which Francisco Lomelí and Clark Colahan translated as "plays in celebration of the birth of the baby Jesus."

In the early years, a coloquio was a part of larger play that could be performed separately. It was much like a rondo within a sonata. It was always part of the larger composition, but followed rules unique to itself, and could be extracted and played separately.

Franciscans adapted Spanish dramatic forms to the Aztec language to induce natives to be baptized. Dominicans and Jesuits expanded the genres.

The most popular were the auto sacramentales, which were mounted on carriages that drove through the streets. Each auto depicted a different scene, and included a coloquio. The ones that survived in New Mexico focused on Joseph, the inns, the shepherds, the magi, Jesus in the temple, and holy week. Arthur Campa noted they survived in fragments and by 1934 had been fused into a single drama.

The coloquio was a dialogue between two characters that had no narrative impulse. James Crawford believed they originated in Italy and were brought to Spain as amusements of the aristocracy. He described them as casuistical, meaning they dramatized two sides of moral questions by applying them to mundane events.

Carlos Eduardo Castañeda noted the coloquio evolved into a simpler dramatic genre "in the form of a dialogue, written either in verse or prose." He said, it "gained special popularity in Mexico."

Eight coloquio written by Miguel de Quintana were preserved in the files of the Holy Office in Ciudad de México. Six were given to Manuel Sopeña in 1732, but only two may been written for him. One was written for José Irigoyen in 1732, and one for Juan Sánchez de la Cruz in 1737.

There were committed in an acuarterón, a kind of personal notebook made from folio pages cut into fourths measuring 4.5" by 6.5." As shown in the photograph of a page made by the translators, he transcribed them as if they were appearing on a printed page with the verses in two columns separated by a commentary written at a right angle. The prose was below.


One coloquio has two sets of verses and prose, but six only have one. One had no prose, while the one he gave to Irigoyen had no marginal commentary.

They all began with the line, "Jesús, María, y José," followed by a four line verses that took the form ABCB. The rhymed lines ended with vowel or assonant sounds.

Cree, Mi-guel, con vi-va fe
que Di-os no te ha con-fun-di-do
ni su di-vi-na gran-de-za
es-tá en-jo-ja-do con-ti-go.

Spanish theorists emphasize the total number of syllables to the line, unlike the English who count the number of stressed syllables (the ones in bold above). Quintana varied his number of syllables, but did tend to make the rhyming second and fourth lines shorter in the style of the seguidilla real that alternated between lines containing 10 and 6 syllables.

Angélico Chávez noted Quintana had a "marked facility in rhyming within the limits of the quatrain in trimeter," meaning three stressed syllables. The translators used the quoted verse to illustrate his "poetic virtuosity" because the verb "enjojado" does not refer to the preceding noun, "grandeza," but to the one before, "Dios."

The verses were dialogues between Miguel and God. Following Franciscan conventions, Miguel was personified as a poor sinner seeking guidance.

Following the coloquios proper, the prose described events which precipitated the conversations. They may have been modeled on instructions for actors or producers. The ones that probably were written before Sopeña threatened to denounce him described the character Miguel

- Seeing a vision of Juan de Tagle
- Being unable to complete a Christmas coloquio and changing to the Miguel series
- Being unable to complete saying the rosary when contemplating the Sorrowful Mysteries

These contained his most vivid writing. Tagle’s ghost was described with his "hands stuck in his sleeves like a dead man’s" with "his eyes being two fountains of tears" and his face, "capilla calada," the color of "a chapel recently whitewashed with lime." Behind him the altar cloths were red, "encarnado."

One of the prose sections specific to Sopeña dealt with the horrors with which Quintana was threatened. The other mentioned Miguel no longer was participating in the Third Order. The one Quintana gave to Irigoyen specifically mentioned threats of the Inquisition.

He wrote another coloquio in 1737 for Cruz. In the prose section, he claimed "The reverend father who is the commissary of the Holy Office and his notary have come, Miguel, with frivolous pretexts dressed in the passions to hit you with a cat-o’-nine tails." The translators noted the original wording, "a dar gatazo," might have been a subtle pun if the word gatazo was derived from catear. The latter implied a conspiracy.

The form he used was neither linear nor was it based on oral tradition, though the translators noted several times when he chose colloquial rather than formal words. If one reads his coloquios as published from top to bottom, one becomes lost in the repetitions. Instead, one should read the prose first, then read the dialogues as illustrations of the moral quandaries raised by events.

Notes: The quoted verse was written in 1737 for Cruz. The translation loses the verbal dexterity:

Believe, Miguel, with living faith
that God has not confused you,
nor is His divine might
angry with you.

Campa, Arthur L. Spanish Religious Folktheatre in the Spanish Southwest (First Cycle), 1934.

Castañeda, Carlos Eduardo. "The First American Play," The Catholic World, January 1932; quoted by Campa.

Chávez, Angélico. "The Mad Poet of Santa Cruz," New Mexico Folklore Record 3:10-17:1949.

Crawford, James Pyle Wickersham. Spanish Drama Before Lope de Vega, 1922; on coloquio.

Hart, Stephen M. A Companion to Latin American Literature, 2007; on development of drama in México.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006; contains Spanish and English versions of all documents described here.

Quintana, Miguel de. Coloquio, 1732 and 1737, reprinted in Spanish and English by Lomelí.

Montaño, Mary Caroline. Tradiciones Nuevomexicanas, 2001; on developments in New Mexico.

Sunday, June 19, 2016

Miguel de Quintana’s Family

Miguel de Quintana came to Nuevo México with the colonists recruited from Mexico City by Cristóbal de Velasco in 1693. He traveled with his wife, Gertrudis de Trujillo, her parents, and her sister’s family.

Gertrudis’ mother, María Ruiz de Aguilar, was the daughter of the Nicolás Ruiz de Aguilar who had angered Franciscans in 1659 when the governor asked him to monitor their pueblo labor practices. The Inquisition in Mexico City found him guilty of "obstructing the missionary program" in 1664. He was caught in the same controversy that ensnared Francisco Gómez Robledo.

Aguilar had married Mariana de los Ángeles Guerrero in 1652 in Ciudad de Mexico. María was born in 1654 in Mexico City. While he was in Santa Fé, he fathered three children with Catalina Marquez. It’s not clear if Mariana had died and Nicolas remarried, or if she stayed south. Catalina’s three boys used her name. One step-brother, Nicolás, and some of their cousins returned with Diego de Vargas.

María was around 11-years-old when her father died in 1666. If Mariana were still alive, the girl might have had dim memories of her father’s situation and more vivid ones from tales told by her mother or stepmother. Quintana may have heard them sometime before María and her husband returned to México in 1705.

Gertrudis’ sister, Estefánia, was married to José de Atienza Sevillano. His father, José de Atienza de Alcalá y Escobar, had migrated to Nueva España from the area of Toledo in Spain. Several hundred years before, people with the same last name in the same area were convicted of being secret Jews, according to Stanley Hordes.

Quintana’s own family was more obscure. All his grandparents were born in Nueva España, with his maternal grandfather, Francisco de Valdés Altamirano, from the Toluca valley. While his wife’s ancestors were classed as meztisos, nothing was said about Miguel in 1673 other than he was of "sound body."

José Esquibel and John Colligan traced the family back to the powerful Álvarez de Toledos. Although long rumored to be conversos, Antonio Domínguez Ortiz said their genealogy suggested they were Christians who had adopted some customs from their Arab conquerors in Al-Ándalus.

Miguel and Gertrudis had at least ten children. A baptismal certificate survives for only one, Nicolás, who was born in 1712. His godparents were Juana Martín Serrano and Diego Marques.

Marriage records for their children and baptismal records for their grandchildren are equally sparse. Two Quintanas married children of María Luján and Pedro Sánchez de Iñigo, whose brother had been alcalde in Santa Cruz in 1713. Michaela married his son Pedro, while her brother Juan Tadeo married Francisca Xaviera.

The 1731 baptismal record for a child of María and Pedro was the first entry in Santa Cruz’s bound register. The names of the godparents were damaged so only Antonio survived for the man, and Magdalen (torn) Vaca for the woman. Juan and Xaviera’s marriage entry survived in better condition. María and Pedro were their witnesses. Their first baptismal entry was made in 1735 with Antonio Tafoya and Prudensia Gonzales as sponsors.

No sacramental records survived for their oldest daughter, Gertrudis Lugarda, who married Ascencio Archuleta. He was the grandson of Juan de Archuleta, but apparently had disappeared long before Lugardia wrote her will in 1749. She had borne three children, but reserved a few things for a niece, one guesses she might have been raising.

The Quintanas’ daughter Antonia does not appear in the Santa Cruz records. Angélico Chávez said her husband was Juan Gómez del Castillo. His mother was Juana Luján, the daughter of Matías. Chávez thought his father was Bartolomé Gómez Robledo, the illegitimate son of Bartolomé. The latter was the brother of the Francisco mentioned above and of Andrés, the father-in-law of Ignacio de Roybal. They probably were living in the San Ildefonso area when their first child was born in 1732.

The first child’s name to appear in the sacramental record after Quintana was denounced by Manuel de Sopeña in March of 1732 was their oldest boy. José had been born in 1698 and married to Lugarda Tafoya when they had a son in April. She had previously been married to Juan Sayago, who was killed during the Villasur expedition in 1720. Chávez thought he might have been related to Francisco de la Rosa, since both also were called González. It’s possible José was also a widow, but all that’s known about him was he was killed by Indians in 1748. The godparents in 1732 were Antonio Tafoya and Prudencia González.

Another son, Francisco Xavier, remarried after Quintana agreed to his fate in January of 1737. He married Juana Martín in September of 1737, with Manuel de la Rosa and Gertrudis Jirón de Tejeda as witnesses. Their first surviving baptismal record was from 1747. Francisco’s first wife, María Rosa Trujillo, died in 1728. It’s not known if she was local or a cousin through one of his mother’s brothers.

Three adolescent boys, beside Juan, were living at home when Quintana was denounced. Their marriages weren’t recorded and their first baptismal records in the Santa Cruz register appeared after 1737. Nicolás, who was 20 in 1732, married Mariana de Herrera; Manuel, who was 16, married María Feliciana Medina, and Juan José, who was 13, married Petronila Romero. Mariana’s family had roots in the Río Abajo before the Revolt. Pedro Asensio Tafoya and Ana sponsored the baptism of her son in 1745.

Feliciana’s maternal grandfather in Chimayó was Cristóbal Martín Serrano. Her paternal grandfather, Diego Medina’s daughter married Diego Romero, the son of Salvador, in 1714. The first recorded sponsors for her children were her parents, José Isidro de Medina and María Catarina Martín in 1743.

Little is known about Juan José and Petronila, except she died in Belen. He may have moved south where he had cousins. His father’s younger brother, José, had come after the Reconquest. He joined the presidio and married Antonia Luján. They moved to Bernalillo, perhaps after her mother, Juana Domínguez, died. Antonia’s father, Domingo Luján, died in 1693. Juana later was accused of living with Lorenzo de Madrid, whom she subsequently married.

Family genealogists have found references to two other children for Miguel and Gertrudis. Juan Baptista was born in 1708 and alive in 1712 when Quintana testified he had seven children. He may have died after that, or moved away.

The other, María, survives, so far, as only a name, with no birth date. She may have died young.

Notes: Gertrudis’ full name was Gertrudis de la Santa Trinidad Moreno de Trujillo. Miguel was born Miguel Matías de Quintana. Juan Sayago also was called Juan Gallegos. Mariana de Herrera also was listed as María Antonia de Herrera. The connections between the Medinas and Martín Serranos in Chimayó were mentioned in the post for 4 November 2015.

Chávez, Angélico. Origins of New Mexico Families, 1992 revised edition.

Domínguez Ortiz, Antonio. Los Judeoconversos en España y América, 1971; quoted in Wikipedia entry on Pedro Álvarez de Toledo.

Esquibel, José A. and John B. Colligan. The Spanish Recolonization of New Mexico, 1999; cited by Hordes on Quintana’s family; cited by López for Aguilar’s marriage in Mexico City.

Geni genealogical website. Entries on Quintana’s family including María Ruiz de Aguilar and her Márquez kin; some are anonymous; other contributions were made by Ben M. Angel, Laura Elaine Chamas-Ortega, Ric Dickinson, Orlando Ricardo Mestas, and Henry Joseph Romero.

Hordes, Stanley M. To the End of the Earth, 2005.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006; contains Spanish and English versions of all documents described.

López, Nancy Lucía. Entry for Mariana de los Ángeles Guerrero on My New México Roots website, updated 25 January 2015.

New Mexico Genealogical Society. New Mexico Baptisms, Santa Cruz de la Cañada Church, Volume I, 1710 to 1794, transcribed by Virginia Langham Olmstead and compiled by Margaret Leonard Windham and Evelyn Luján Baca, 1994.

_____. 100 Years of Marriages, 1726-1826, Santa Cruz de la Cañada, New Mexico, extracted and compiled by Henrietta Martinez Christmas and Patricia Sánchez Rau.

Quintana, Lugarda de. Will, Santa Cruz, 1749; in Lomelí. She wrote "my husband is absent, and I do not know where."

Quintana, Miguel de. Lawsuit against Joseph Trujillo for a theft of two horses, 8 August to 24 October, 1712; in Lomelí.

Sánchez, Joseph E. "Nicolás de Aguilar and the Jurisdiction of Salinas in the Province of New Mexico, 1659-1662," Revista Complutense de Historia de América 22:139-160:1996; quotation on Aguilar.

Velázquez de la Cadena, Pedro. List of families going to New Mexico, 4 September 1693, in John L. Kessell, Rick Hendricks, and Meredith Dodge, To the Royal Crown Restored, 1995.

Sunday, June 12, 2016

Inquisition versus Miguel de Quintana

The official record of the Inquisition’s proceedings against Miguel de Quintana is presented below.

1732 March 17
Around 5 pm on the Monday that began the third week of Lent, Manuel de Sopeña reported he had been given nine sheets of paper "containing many reckless and scandalous assertions" by Quintana. His statement before the commissary of the Holy Office, José Antonio Guerrero, was notarized by José Irigoyen. Sopeña identified himself as the "minister of Nueva Villa de Santa Cruz."

1732 June 29
Quintana told Irigoyen he could not "comply with the obligation of annually going to confession and taking Communion," because "God did not ask the impossible of any of His children." He give the friar a paper justifying his refusal.

1732 July 1
Irigoyen denounced Quintana to the Holy Office, and notarized his own statement.

1732 July 12
Guerrero sent Quintana’s papers with the statements by Sopeña and Irigoyen to the Inquisition’s Holy Tribunal in Ciudad de México.

1734 May 22
The Inquisition in Mexico City reviewed Quintana’s case in its Secret Court. The men’s initial conclusion was "the case may well stem from feeblemindedness," but allowed the possibility that he was "ruled by some evil spirit." However, they said, they could not "form an opinion" because they knew nothing of this "life and habits, his abilities and talents." The Inquisitor, Diego Mangado y Cavijo, returned the paperwork to Guerrero "to reexamine and verify the statements of the two friars, according to standard directions." The Santa Fé commissary also was told to interview Quintana.

1734 May 27
Two inquisitors wrote a letter of instructions to Guerrero. In addition to the above, they told him to officially warn Quintana "drawing his attention to this court’s order that he should not inwardly believe or outwardly express such heretical assertions and that failure to comply will lead to prosecution to the fullest extent of the law." They further instructed him to have Quintana "sign a promise of obedience."

1734 November 4
Manuel de Sopeña was recalled from Picurís, but was no longer sure how many sheets of writing had been given to him by Quintana. When asked, he said the man "has his lucid intervals, but he is not completely convinced he is in his right mind, as witnessed by an occasion when he is said to have thrown stones. He does not recall who told him that, but people say that it must be fifteen years ago when this happened."

Sopeña also noted Quintana sometimes had trouble speaking when he was helping him with mass, "rarely goes to mass, giving as an excuse pain in the spleen," and did not participate in the Third Order of Saint Francis, the one open the laymen. He was told his testimony was to be kept secret. Irigoyen was the witness.

1734 November 5
Irigoyen, who was now described as a retired preacher, was recalled. Witnesses to the secret proceedings were the Franciscan’s vice custos and Francisco Manuel Bravo Lerchundi, the missionary to Pecos. The notary was José de Eguía.

The friar remembered it was around 9 in the morning on July 1 of 1732 that he had submitted his signed denunciation. He adds he told Quintana to confess on June 19 around 11 in the morning. He admitted he did not "know whether Quintana regularly takes the most holy sacraments or does virtuous actions," but does not attribute his actions "to madness or simplemindedness." He found not "a single thing to add, change or modify" in his first statement.

1734 November 8
Quintana was interrogated by Joseph Antonio Guerrero in secret in Santa Fé, with Irigoyen as the witness. Quintana explained why he thought God put "these thoughts in his mind."

1734 November 10
Guerrero sent a report to Inquisition in Ciudad de México that said he had questioned Sopeña, Irigoyen, and Quintana as instructed. He added that, since there was no sign Quintana was not mentally deficient in anyway, "I did not bring to his attention the extreme seriousness of the matter, nor did I officially warn him of the consequences as instructed."

1735 March 15
Authorities in Mexico City reviewed the documents sent by Guerrero. They noted he didn’t warn Quintana as instructed.

1735 March 24
Diego Mangado y Clavijo decided Quintana was suffering "from some delusion or damage to the imagination." He ordered Guerrero to make Quintana "appear before him and a notary, place him under oath, and warm him along the safe and easy path, which is in keeping of the commandments of God and His Holy Church, threatening him that if he should slip back into his ravings, the Holy Office will treat him with all severity." He also told Guerrero to give him a "learned and prudent confessor to him to hear his confessions."

1736 March 11
Guerrero sent more papers to Mexico City that said "Quintana was sick in bed, as he is now, and to judge by his condition, near death."

1736 July 24
Inquisitors in Ciudad de México acknowledged receipt of Guerrero’s report. They ordered him again to confront Quintana in the presence of a notary and tell him "not to publicize or tell anyone at all about these ravings he calls revelations or inspirations." He was to warn him, if he continued, he "would be treated with all the severity of the law and subject to the punishments applied to the obstinate, a fraud, and a rebel."

1737 January 22
Irigoyen went to Quintana’s house to order him to appear in Santa Fé, but found he was too sick to obey.

1737 January 23
Guerrero went to Quintana’s house at "about nine o’clock in the morning" to tell him "he should have nothing more to do with ridiculous revelations and publicizing them under the penalty of being punished as someone obstinate, a fraud, and a rebel." Quintana agreed. Guerrero assigned Irigoyen as his confessor.

Notes: Francisco A. Lomelí and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006; contains Spanish and English versions of all documents described here.

Sunday, June 05, 2016

José Irigoyen

Benito Crespo visited Santa Cruz in 1730 as part of his review of Franciscan missions within the bishopric of Durango. He reported that Christianized natives in Nuevo México, without specifying where, refused to confess to priests who didn’t speak their languages. His later list of the most negligent priests included Manuel de Sopeña of Santa Clara, Juan Sánchez de la Cruz of San Juan de los Caballeros, José Irigoyen of San Ildefonso, Antonio Gabaldón of Nambé, and Juan José Pérez de Mirabal of Taos.

One consequence of Crespo’s asserting his authority was friars no longer could excommunicate parishioners without his approval. Rather than provoke the bishop into defending his privileges, Irigoyen denounced a Santa Cruz poet and dramatist to the Inquisition in 1732 for refusing to confess to him or Sopeña. By then, Miguel de Quintana’s mind had become so fevered, the Holy Office in Ciudad de México demanded evidence he wasn’t feebleminded.

Irigoyen may have felt maligned by Crespo. Juan Miguel Menchero had depositions from two alcaldes that claimed the friar had "mastered the various Tanoan subgroups, despite being transferred often among those pueblos." In fact he spent time in two Towa speaking pueblos (Jémez, Pecos), two Tiwa (Isleta, Picurís), one Tano (Galiesteo), and two Tewa (Tesuque, Nambé).

The Franciscan also was assigned to four Keres locations (Ácoma, Cochití, San Felipe, Zía), who did not speak a Tanoan language. Except for the two local Tewa-speaking communities (San Ildefonso, Santa Clara), he didn’t spend two full years in any non-Castilian speaking mission.

Jim Norris published biographical details about the six priests who names appeared in the proceedings against Quintana. Three were born in Spain, Pérez de Mirabal in Málaga and Sánchez de la Cruz from some unknown location. Juan de Tagle, who was dead by the time Crespo visited the kingdom, was a Cantabrian and, apparently, close to Quintana.

The other three were first-generation criollos. Joseph Antonio Guerrero’s father came from Madrid, Sopeña’s from Viscaya, and Irigoyen’s from Navarre. The first two entered the convento grande de San Francisco in Mexico City. Irigoyen went through San Francisco de Puebla.

I don’t know if the conflicts between the two cultural groups mentioned in the post for 30 March 2016 infiltrated the Franciscan training centers, or if the two groups simply had different responses to the same situations based on childhood or adolescent experiences. It remains, the native-born friars were the ones who attacked Quintana, who himself probably was trained at the cathedral school in Ciudad de México.

I also don’t know if friars from Mexico City had more status than those from Puebla at the missionary school they both attended. What does seem clear is that Irigoyen was particularly eager to distinguish himself. He was the youngest of the men, professed in 1716 at age 17 and, at 27, one of the youngest sent to Nuevo México. Until he reached San Ildefonso in 1730, his longest assignements had been 16 months as Galisteo, 13 months at Isleta and 10 months at San Felipe. He later joined the friars proselytizing the Navajo.

Knowledge about Irigoyen is important because there are two versions of events in Santa Cruz. He controlled the official record as notary to the Inquisition office in Santa Fé headed by Guerrero. As such, he not only collected all the key documents, but also highlighted the heretical passages before they were sent to Mexico City.

The second version is the one that must be teased from details of Quintana’s life and from parsing translations of official documents.

Notes: Lomelí and Colahan made an important point about the differences between saying Nueva México and Nuevo México, and suggested the timing of the transition from one to the other was significant. Unfortunately, so many translators have been oblivious to such nuances, that it’s impossible to know which term were used without consulting their primary sources. For this reason, I am standardizing on the modern usage of Nuevo.

The post for 10 April 2016 has more on Irigoyen’s work with the Navajo. The post for 6 April 2016 discussed the missionary training school at Santiago de Tlatelolco where New Mexico friars were trained.

Chávez, Angélico. Archives of the Archdiocese of Santa Fe, 1678-1900, 1957.

Crespo y Monroy, Benito. Letter to the viceroy, Juan Vásquez de Acuña, 8 September 1730; translation in Eleanor B. Adams, Bishop Tamarón’s Visitation of New Mexico, 1760, 1954; see post for 3 April 2016 for more details.

_____. Memorial ajustado que de órden del consejo supremo de Indias se ha hecho del pleyto, que siguió el Illmo, Madrid, 1738; cited by Hubert Howe Bancroft, History of Arizona and New Mexico, 1530-1888, 1889. Bancroft listed five others as also negligent.

Esquibel, José Antonio. "The People of the Camino Real: A Genealogical Appendix," in Christine Preston, Douglas Preston and José Antonio Esquibel, The Royal Road, 1998; on Quintana’s education.

Lomelí, Francisco A. and Clark A. Colahan. Defying the Inquisition in Colonial New Mexico, 2006.

Mangado y Calvijo, Diego. Instructions to Joseph Antonio Guerrero, 22 May 1734, Ciudad de México; translation in Lomelí and Collahan.

Norris, Jim. After "The Year Eighty," 2000.