Stereotypes of Neanderthal life abound. Facts are limited to what can be deduced from the bones and stones they left.
Remains of twelve individuals from 49,000 years ago were found at El Sidrón, in the Cantabrian range of Asturias in northern Spain. That’s during the devastating cold spell mentioned in the post for 29 July. Evidence suggests the Neanderthals were eaten, and their bones left together. They later fell through an opening when the limestone cave’s roof collapsed, probably during a flood.
The twelve must have been members of a single band composed of three adult men and three adult women, along with two teenage males, and a male child. The genders of the other adult, the other teenager and the infant couldn’t be determined.
The three men were brothers. The women were not related, and had come to live with the band. One adolescent and one of the children were brothers, born about three years apart. No comment has been made on the absence of young girls in the group.
It’s likely the band had moved outside its ancestral range in northern Europe, and interbred with people already in the south. A jaw bone had the character of northern Neanderthals, while the faces showed the broadness and lowness associated with southern ones.
The climate was cold and dry. In Catalonia to the east, Francesc Burjachs and Ethel Allué found pollens from composites, sage brushes, and grasses in those millennia. Scattered Scots pines survived in the dry steppes.
Yarrow was surely one of the composites. One subspecies, Ceretanica, is a relic of the Pleistocene Pyrenees. Achillea millefolium spread into North America from a refuge in Bergenia and, today, grows nearly everywhere from the far north of the Yukon to Honduras. You sometimes see it here along the roadside.
Few animal bones were found among the litter at El Sidrón. Antonio Rosas’ team identified a red deer with "very few small mammals and gastropods." When Karen Hardy’s group examined plaque from the Neanderthals’ teeth, they found "few lipids or proteins from meat."
The teeth showed signs of dietary deprivation, often from the fourth and twelfth years of life. The enamel of five individuals indicated they’d been malnourished twice and one person had suffered four times. One of the adolescents had lived through "an exceptionally severe episode of physiological stress"
In the absence of meat they were relying on plants. Hardy’s team found the plaque contained "a
range of carbohydrates and starch granules." They also found "evidence for inhalation of wood-fire smoke and bitumen or oil shale." The starches were so changed by roasting, they couldn’t be identified.
Roasting requires close contact with fire. Perhaps they used sticks to manipulate foods. Yarrow is slow to ignite, and stays green in most winters. It might have been grasped like a potholder for protection.
No wooden tools have survived from El Sidrón. The ones found were stone. The only adaptation to changed circumstances was most used local chert. A few were fashioned from quartzite.
Burns must have been a problem. The two plants Hardy’s team could identify, yarrow and camomile, have both been used to treat burns and other skin injuries. They were probably chewed raw and either spat onto the wound, or the wounded finger was sucked. It’s been used that way in recent times by the Zuñi in New Mexico, the Crow of Montana, the Cree of Saskatchewan, and the Bella Coola of British Columbia.
The chewed plant has been used to treat toothaches by the Cree and Paiute. Rosas’ colleagues found one of the El Sidrón individuals at had had an abscess caused by periodontitis associated with biting hard. They noted, "This sort of lesion is common among Neandertal lineage populations."
The other physical problem Neanderthals were known to have, broken bones, wasn’t mentioned for El Sidrón. Elsewhere, Thomas Berger and Erik Trinkas found nearly all the bodies that survived showed signs of fracture and healing. Most had three or four wounds, primarily to the upper body. The trauma pattern closely resembled injuries suffered by today’s rodeo competitors.
Trinkas noted, they didn’t find any broken leg bones among the Neanderthal relics. That kind of injury must have been fatal in a mobile band. No broken bones in a band meant they either weren’t eating meat, were left behind or, possibly, were eaten.
Notes: Red deer is Cervus elaphus, sage bush is Artemisia, Scots pine is Pinus sylvestris, chamomile is Anthemis nobilis. Generic yarrow is Achillea millefolium, the Pyrenees subspecies is Achillea millefolium ceretanica.
Aleksoff, Keith C. "Achillea millefolium," 1991, in U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Fire Effects Information System.
Burjachs, F. and E. Allué. "Paleoclimatic Evolution During the Last Glacial Cycle at the NE of
the Iberian Peninsula," in María Blanca Ruiz Zapata, et alia, Quaternary Climatic Changes and Environmental Crises in the Mediterranean Region, 2003.
Hardy, Karen, Carles Lalueza-Fox, et alia. "Neanderthal Medics? Evidence for Food, Cooking, and Medicinal Plants Entrapped in Dental Calculus," Naturwissenschaften 99:617-626:2012; quotation on smoke.
_____. Discussed by Matt Kaplan in "Neanderthals Ate Their Greens," Nature website, 18 July 2012; quotations on lipids and starches.
Hirst, K. Kris. "El Sidrón - Evidence for Neanderthal Cannibalism in Spain," About Archaeology website.
Lalueza-Fox, Carles, Antonio Rosas, et alia. "Genetic Evidence for Patrilocal Mating Behavior among Neandertal Groups," National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings 108:250-253:2011.
Moerman, Dan. Native American Ethnobotany, 1998, summarizes data from a number of ethnographies.
Rosas, Antonio, Carles Lalueza-Fox, et alia. "Paleobiology and Comparative Morphology of a Late Neandertal Sample from El Sidrón, Asturias, Spain," National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings 103:19266-19271:2006; quotation on dietary stress.
Trinkas, Erik. Quoted in "Evidence Suggests Skulduggery among the Neanderthals," The Washington Post, 23 April 2002.
_____ and T. D. Berger. "Patterns of Trauma among Neadertals," Journal of Archaeological Science 22:841-852:1996
Showing posts with label 29 Spain (1-5). Show all posts
Showing posts with label 29 Spain (1-5). Show all posts
Wednesday, August 05, 2015
Sunday, August 02, 2015
Neanderthal Tools: La Cueva de los Aviones
Neanderthals, especially those inhabiting areas to the north of the Iberia peninsula, relied primarily on flint for their tools. Paul Mellars noted a strong "coincidence between raw material distributions and the occurrence of the richer and more intensively occupied open-air sites" in southwestern France. In Spain, flint nodules only occurred in the area of Cap Salou on the Catalonian coast.
When flint wasn’t available, tool makers substituted chert, a similar silica rock. Its primary location in Spain was the Jurassic layers in the Sistema Ibérico.
Perhaps because flint wasn’t as widely distributed as the animals they hunted, early Neanderthal tool makers developed techniques that produced more flakes from a nodule than previous methods. Once formed, Jean-Pierre Bocquet-Appel and Alain Tuffreau said, Mousterian technology didn’t change.
Southern Neanderthals who sought refuge in southeastern Spain during the cold spell 50,000 years ago still used flint for sidescrapers and points, but were forced to adapt quartz for their other tools. Their diet also expanded to include local species. They left behind marine mollusk shells and rabbit and tortoise bones along with those of horses, deer, and ibex.
La Cueva de los Aviones was less than five miles from the Mediterranean. João Zilhão’s team found the local Neanderthals not only ate local varieties of cockles, mussels, and limpets, but also some that weren’t local. They believed they must have wrapped the dog whelks in algae to prevent them from spoiling on the journey back to the cave.
The archaeologists noticed that some of the shells they found were from inedible species. Many had holes from 4.5 mm to 6.5 mm in diameter. While nature and weather could have produced holes, they believed these specific clam shells were selected because they could be strung into ornaments.
Glycymeris nummaria shells are nearly circular with a diameter that can reach 2.4 inches across. According to Wikipedia, they’re marked by radiating, concentric lines. The exterior is dull, usually a dark or pale brown. The inside is " glossy, white or pale yellow, often with irregular brown markings."
Hematite residues were found on one of the clam shells. Researchers found the nearest source for the iron oxide was two or three miles away in the modern mining district of La Unión.
More interesting than the ornamental clam shell was a spiny oyster shell that had contained "a red lepidocrocite base mixed with ground particles of charcoal, dolomite, hematite, and pyrite." Zilhão’s group thought it was either used for mixing or storing pigments.
The existence of a container implies the development of one of the necessary concepts that allowed individuals to move beyond being dependent on what was found each day to storing food for later use and for boiling it.
Notes:
Bocquet-Appel, Jean-Pierre and Alain Tuffreau (April–June 2009). "Technological Responses of Neanderthals to Macroclimatic Variations (240,000-40,000 BP)," Human Biology 81:287-307:2009.
Gibbons, Wes and Teresa Moreno. The Geology of Spain, 2002; on locations of flint.
Gómez, J. J. and S. R. Fernández-López. "The Iberian Middle Jurassic Carbonate-Platform System: Synthesis of the Palaeogeographic Elements of Its Eastern Margin (Spain)," Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 236:190-205:2006; on locations of chert.
Mellars, Paul. The Neanderthal Legacy, 1996.
Wikipedia, on the mollusk species.
Zilhão, João, et alia. "Symbolic Use of Marine Shells and Mineral Pigments by Iberian Neandertals," National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings 107:1023-1028:2010.
The edible local species were:
Cerastoderma - common cockle
Monodonta - sea snail
Mytilus - saltwater mussel
Patella - limpet
The non-local edible species were:
Nassarius incrassatus - thick-lipped dogwhelk
Gibbula - small sea snail
The ornamental species was:
Glycymeris insubrica/nummaria - bittersweet clam
The utilitarian species was:
Spondylus gaederopus - European spiny oyster
When flint wasn’t available, tool makers substituted chert, a similar silica rock. Its primary location in Spain was the Jurassic layers in the Sistema Ibérico.
Perhaps because flint wasn’t as widely distributed as the animals they hunted, early Neanderthal tool makers developed techniques that produced more flakes from a nodule than previous methods. Once formed, Jean-Pierre Bocquet-Appel and Alain Tuffreau said, Mousterian technology didn’t change.
Southern Neanderthals who sought refuge in southeastern Spain during the cold spell 50,000 years ago still used flint for sidescrapers and points, but were forced to adapt quartz for their other tools. Their diet also expanded to include local species. They left behind marine mollusk shells and rabbit and tortoise bones along with those of horses, deer, and ibex.
La Cueva de los Aviones was less than five miles from the Mediterranean. João Zilhão’s team found the local Neanderthals not only ate local varieties of cockles, mussels, and limpets, but also some that weren’t local. They believed they must have wrapped the dog whelks in algae to prevent them from spoiling on the journey back to the cave.
The archaeologists noticed that some of the shells they found were from inedible species. Many had holes from 4.5 mm to 6.5 mm in diameter. While nature and weather could have produced holes, they believed these specific clam shells were selected because they could be strung into ornaments.
Glycymeris nummaria shells are nearly circular with a diameter that can reach 2.4 inches across. According to Wikipedia, they’re marked by radiating, concentric lines. The exterior is dull, usually a dark or pale brown. The inside is " glossy, white or pale yellow, often with irregular brown markings."
Hematite residues were found on one of the clam shells. Researchers found the nearest source for the iron oxide was two or three miles away in the modern mining district of La Unión.
More interesting than the ornamental clam shell was a spiny oyster shell that had contained "a red lepidocrocite base mixed with ground particles of charcoal, dolomite, hematite, and pyrite." Zilhão’s group thought it was either used for mixing or storing pigments.
The existence of a container implies the development of one of the necessary concepts that allowed individuals to move beyond being dependent on what was found each day to storing food for later use and for boiling it.
Notes:
Bocquet-Appel, Jean-Pierre and Alain Tuffreau (April–June 2009). "Technological Responses of Neanderthals to Macroclimatic Variations (240,000-40,000 BP)," Human Biology 81:287-307:2009.
Gibbons, Wes and Teresa Moreno. The Geology of Spain, 2002; on locations of flint.
Gómez, J. J. and S. R. Fernández-López. "The Iberian Middle Jurassic Carbonate-Platform System: Synthesis of the Palaeogeographic Elements of Its Eastern Margin (Spain)," Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 236:190-205:2006; on locations of chert.
Mellars, Paul. The Neanderthal Legacy, 1996.
Wikipedia, on the mollusk species.
Zilhão, João, et alia. "Symbolic Use of Marine Shells and Mineral Pigments by Iberian Neandertals," National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings 107:1023-1028:2010.
The edible local species were:
Cerastoderma - common cockle
Monodonta - sea snail
Mytilus - saltwater mussel
Patella - limpet
The non-local edible species were:
Nassarius incrassatus - thick-lipped dogwhelk
Gibbula - small sea snail
The ornamental species was:
Glycymeris insubrica/nummaria - bittersweet clam
The utilitarian species was:
Spondylus gaederopus - European spiny oyster
Sunday, June 14, 2015
Oldowan Life in Spain
Oldowan tool functions are unknown. Those who believed the earliest pre-human species were hunters argued they were used for butchering and for breaking bones to retrieve marrow or brains. Others said wear patterns on stone didn’t support that interpretation. Mary Douglas Leakey suggested some were used to pound plants. Her husband, Louis Leakey, thought the hominins were scavengers who ate remains of large mammals killed by carnivores.
Stone tools found in East African sites are so old, they don’t reveal the same information specialists can tease from Neanderthal artifacts. Bones have cut marks that could have come from butchering or hyenas or weathering. Geologists have only been able to confirm the Gona river area supported C4 grass. Pollen studies haven’t been able to identify available species.
At Sima del Elefante, in the Atapuerca, archaeologists have recovered bones of horses from every level, with bison, rhinoceroses, jaguars and lynx at the lowest level. They also found traces of conifers and oaks from the early years of the Pre-Pastorian glacial period around 1.3 million years ago.
In the higher strata they found evidence the climate alternated between colder and warmer. Right above the first layer, they found antlered deer, Irish elk, foxes and rabbits. Still higher, they again found bison, this time with charcoal. Then, the cave yielded antlered deer, Irish elk, foxes, lynxes, bears, and rabbits. At the top of that segment were remains of hippopotamuses, bison, bears, foxes, and rabbits.
More is known from the Aurora level of Gran Dolina at the close of the Pre-Pastorian period that ended just before the Brunhes-Matuyama polar reversal 781,000 years ago. The climate became progressive drier through strata that included remains of Homo antecessor. The number of species of small animals was increasing in an open environment with few forests.
One of the tools had been used to cut a hide, and another was used on wood. However, there is no evidence they used fire. Most tools were used to butcher animals. Evidence of plant use has not survived.
Carlos Díez’s group noted that most of the animal bones butchered in the cave were from small to medium sized mammals, like deer and boars. Deer antlers were "intensively chewed." The larger mammals included bison, horses, and Irish elk. Only teeth were found from rhinoceroses and mammoths, suggesting they were dismembered elsewhere and only the meatiest pieces brought inside. They didn’t mention rodents and rabbits. Any carnivore marks on bones came later.
The Homo antecessor bones also showed they’d been butchered. They were all from children or youth, of both sexes, up to an estimated age of twenty years. Eudald Carbonell’s team concluded people in the cave were cannibals. The dismembered bones appear in every level of the Aurora stratum at Gran Dolina, with no signs of rituals or famine associated with them. They simply were left with the other bones, tools and debris on the cave floor.
Notes:
Ash, Patricia J. and David J. Robinson. The Emergence of Humans, 2010.
Blumenschine, Robert J. "Characteristics of an Early Hominid Scavenging Niche," Current Anthropology 28:383-407:1987, with comments by others.
Carbonell, Eudald, et alia. "Cultural Cannibalism as a Paleoeconomic System in the European Lower Pleistocene: The Case of Level TD6 of Gran Dolina (Sierra de Atapuerca, Burgos, Spain)," Current Anthropology 51:539-549:2010.
Cerling, Thure E., et alia. "Woody Cover and Hominin Environments in the past 6? Million Years," Nature 476:51-56:2011.
Díez, J. Carlos, et alia. Zooarchaeology and Taphonomy of Aurora Stratum (Gran Dolina, Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain)," Journal of Human Evolution 37:623-652:1999. Their list includes:
Small mammals
Fallow deer, roe deer
Wild boar - Sus scrofa
Medium mammals
Red deer
Generic deer - Cervidae
Large mammals
Bovid, Bison - Bison voigtstedtenensis
Horse - Equus stenonian
Irish Elk - Megaloceros
Very large mammals
Rhinoceros - Stephanorhinus etruscus
Mammoth - Mammuthus (only one)
Carnivores
Fox - Vulpes praeglacialis
Bear - Ursus dolinensis
Spotted hyena - Crocuta crocuta
Lynx - Lynx sp.
Leakey, Louis. Cited by G. Teleki, "The Omnivorous Diet and Eclectic Feeding Habits of Chimpanzees in Gombe National Park, Tanzania," in R. S. O. Harding, and G. Teleki, Omnivorous Primates, 1981.
Leakey, Mary. Cited by Nancy M. Tanner, On Becoming Human, 1981.
López Antoñanzas, Raquel and Gloria Cuenca Bescós. "The Gran Dolina Site (Lower to Middle Pleistocene, Atapuerca, Burgos, Spain): New Palaeoenvironmental Data Based on the Distribution of Small Mammals," Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 186:311-334:2002.
Quade, Jay, et alia. "Paleoenvironments of the Earliest Stone Toolmakers, Gona, Ethiopia," Geological Society of America, Bulletin 116:1529-1544:2004.
Rosas, A., et alia. "The "Sima del Elefante" cave site at Atapuerca (Spain)," Estudios Geológicos 62:327-348:2006. The species were:
Antlered deer - Eucladoceros giulli
Bison
Hippopotamus - Hippopotamus
Horse - Equus estenoniano
Irish elk - Megaloceros savinii
Rabbit
Rhinoceros - Rinocerotidae
Carnivores
Bear - Ursus dolinensis
Fox - Vulpes alopecoides
Jaguar - Panthera gombaszoegensis
Lynx - Lynx issodorensis
Photograph: Mario Modesto Mata, "Sierra de Atapuerca," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 22 July 2006.
Stone tools found in East African sites are so old, they don’t reveal the same information specialists can tease from Neanderthal artifacts. Bones have cut marks that could have come from butchering or hyenas or weathering. Geologists have only been able to confirm the Gona river area supported C4 grass. Pollen studies haven’t been able to identify available species.
At Sima del Elefante, in the Atapuerca, archaeologists have recovered bones of horses from every level, with bison, rhinoceroses, jaguars and lynx at the lowest level. They also found traces of conifers and oaks from the early years of the Pre-Pastorian glacial period around 1.3 million years ago.
In the higher strata they found evidence the climate alternated between colder and warmer. Right above the first layer, they found antlered deer, Irish elk, foxes and rabbits. Still higher, they again found bison, this time with charcoal. Then, the cave yielded antlered deer, Irish elk, foxes, lynxes, bears, and rabbits. At the top of that segment were remains of hippopotamuses, bison, bears, foxes, and rabbits.
More is known from the Aurora level of Gran Dolina at the close of the Pre-Pastorian period that ended just before the Brunhes-Matuyama polar reversal 781,000 years ago. The climate became progressive drier through strata that included remains of Homo antecessor. The number of species of small animals was increasing in an open environment with few forests.
One of the tools had been used to cut a hide, and another was used on wood. However, there is no evidence they used fire. Most tools were used to butcher animals. Evidence of plant use has not survived.
Carlos Díez’s group noted that most of the animal bones butchered in the cave were from small to medium sized mammals, like deer and boars. Deer antlers were "intensively chewed." The larger mammals included bison, horses, and Irish elk. Only teeth were found from rhinoceroses and mammoths, suggesting they were dismembered elsewhere and only the meatiest pieces brought inside. They didn’t mention rodents and rabbits. Any carnivore marks on bones came later.
The Homo antecessor bones also showed they’d been butchered. They were all from children or youth, of both sexes, up to an estimated age of twenty years. Eudald Carbonell’s team concluded people in the cave were cannibals. The dismembered bones appear in every level of the Aurora stratum at Gran Dolina, with no signs of rituals or famine associated with them. They simply were left with the other bones, tools and debris on the cave floor.
Notes:
Ash, Patricia J. and David J. Robinson. The Emergence of Humans, 2010.
Blumenschine, Robert J. "Characteristics of an Early Hominid Scavenging Niche," Current Anthropology 28:383-407:1987, with comments by others.
Carbonell, Eudald, et alia. "Cultural Cannibalism as a Paleoeconomic System in the European Lower Pleistocene: The Case of Level TD6 of Gran Dolina (Sierra de Atapuerca, Burgos, Spain)," Current Anthropology 51:539-549:2010.
Cerling, Thure E., et alia. "Woody Cover and Hominin Environments in the past 6? Million Years," Nature 476:51-56:2011.
Díez, J. Carlos, et alia. Zooarchaeology and Taphonomy of Aurora Stratum (Gran Dolina, Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain)," Journal of Human Evolution 37:623-652:1999. Their list includes:
Small mammals
Fallow deer, roe deer
Wild boar - Sus scrofa
Medium mammals
Red deer
Generic deer - Cervidae
Large mammals
Bovid, Bison - Bison voigtstedtenensis
Horse - Equus stenonian
Irish Elk - Megaloceros
Very large mammals
Rhinoceros - Stephanorhinus etruscus
Mammoth - Mammuthus (only one)
Carnivores
Fox - Vulpes praeglacialis
Bear - Ursus dolinensis
Spotted hyena - Crocuta crocuta
Lynx - Lynx sp.
Leakey, Louis. Cited by G. Teleki, "The Omnivorous Diet and Eclectic Feeding Habits of Chimpanzees in Gombe National Park, Tanzania," in R. S. O. Harding, and G. Teleki, Omnivorous Primates, 1981.
Leakey, Mary. Cited by Nancy M. Tanner, On Becoming Human, 1981.
López Antoñanzas, Raquel and Gloria Cuenca Bescós. "The Gran Dolina Site (Lower to Middle Pleistocene, Atapuerca, Burgos, Spain): New Palaeoenvironmental Data Based on the Distribution of Small Mammals," Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 186:311-334:2002.
Quade, Jay, et alia. "Paleoenvironments of the Earliest Stone Toolmakers, Gona, Ethiopia," Geological Society of America, Bulletin 116:1529-1544:2004.
Rosas, A., et alia. "The "Sima del Elefante" cave site at Atapuerca (Spain)," Estudios Geológicos 62:327-348:2006. The species were:
Antlered deer - Eucladoceros giulli
Bison
Hippopotamus - Hippopotamus
Horse - Equus estenoniano
Irish elk - Megaloceros savinii
Rabbit
Rhinoceros - Rinocerotidae
Carnivores
Bear - Ursus dolinensis
Fox - Vulpes alopecoides
Jaguar - Panthera gombaszoegensis
Lynx - Lynx issodorensis
Photograph: Mario Modesto Mata, "Sierra de Atapuerca," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 22 July 2006.
Thursday, June 11, 2015
Spain’s Oldowan Technology
Early human history is the record of technological advances. Tools made from stone survive. Geology was the first science.
The earliest have been found in Gona, Ethiopia, located at the northern end of the East African rift valley in the Afar triangle where the Arabian, Somalian and main African plates are pulling away from each other. Olduvai Gorge, which gave its name to the technology, is at the southern end of the valley in modern Tanzania.
Gona tools have been dated to 2.6 million years ago. That’s just before the Gauss-Matuyama reversal in the Earth’s magnetic field at the beginning of the Pleistocene. Many had volcanic origins. Tool makers held a rock with one hand and struck it with another rock held by the other hand. The chips or flakes were the tool, not the diminished stone. Most had an edge on one side. They looked like choppers and scrappers.
The trachytic basalt cobbles were taken from a nearby stream, and carried elsewhere to be worked. The stone workers, usually called flint knappers, selected fine-grained rocks. The fact other rocks were available indicated they had spent time observing stones and remembering the ones with best qualities.
Technology is transportable. Gona’s techniques spread from Africa, where they were used until 1.7 million year ago. Although the above map only shows significant sites in Asia and Europe, Oldowan tools have been recorded in northern Spain after the industry faded from the Rift Valley. Sima del Elefante has artifacts made from chert, quartz, and limestone dated between 1.4 and 1.1 million years. Gran Dolina has quartzite tools from 800,000 years ago.
Both caves are in the Atapuerca formation less than 10 miles east of Burgos. The isolated limestone formation stood above waters running through the Bureba Pass pass between the Cantabrian mountains to the north and the Sistema Iberia abutting from the south during the Cenozoic. It’s the narrow yellow section toward the north on the map below.
The Oldowan quartzite probably came from terraces of the Arlanzón river that flows through Burgos to meet a tributary of the Duero. The Atapuerca chert formed in the later Miocene when silica grew into nodules within the limestone. Flint forms when the limestone is chalky. Limestone is a form of calcium carbonate.
The basalt of Gona and the quartzite and chert of Atapuerca contain silica dioxide (SiO2), the major component in glass and in sand. They break along clear planes with sharp edges, but those planes aren’t visible like they are with mica. Sileshi Semaw believed the ability to fracture them by striking signified a high level of skill and coordination.
Manufacturing techniques and their associated economies survived changes in biology and culture. The earliest bones associated with Oldowan tools were Australopithecus garhi. The modified rocks also have been found with Homo habilis, Homo ergaster, and Homo erectus.
The Gona tools were found along a tributary of the Awash river, upstream and a bit west of Hadar where Lucy, the oldest human ancestor, was found. The Australopithecus afarensis remains are 3.2 million years old. They haven’t been associated with tools.
At Gran Dolina the Oldowan technology was expanded to include chips of different sizes used for different purposes by Homo antecessor. José Bermúdez de Castro’s team believed the species was the immediate ancestor of Neanderthals. While it had the nasal area of the modern species, its jaws and teeth were like those of Homo erectus.
Innovation has two phases. First comes the invention of a technique, then the modification of that idea to fit new circumstances. Both involve a willingness to experiment, an ability to learn from experience, and an expectation of repeatability. Anyone can throw a rock at a boulder to break off a chip, but only a tool maker will watch the arc and aim another to change the outcome to fit a desired end.
Notes:
Bermúdez de Castro, J. M., et alia. "A Hominid from the Lower Pleistocene of Atapuerca, Spain: Possible Ancestor to Neandertals and Modern Humans," Science 276:1392-1395:1997.
Carbonell, Eudald, Paula García-Medrano, et alia. "The Earliest Acheulean Technology at Atapuerca (Burgos, Spain): Oldest Levels of the Galería Site (Gii Unit)," Quaternary International 353:170-194:2014.
Semaw, Sileshi. "The World’s Oldest Stone Artefacts from Gona, Ethiopia: Their Implications for Understanding Stone Technology and Patterns of Human Evolution Between 2.6-1.5 Million Years Ago," Journal of Archaeological Science 27:1197-1214:2000.
____, Jay Quade, et alia. "Paleoenvironments of the Earliest Stone Toolmakers, Gona, Ethiopia," Geological Society of America, Bulletin 116:1529-1544:2004.
Toro Moyano, Isidro, et alia. "The Archaic Stone Tool Industry from Barranco León and Fuente Nueva 3, (Orce, Spain): Evidence of the Earliest Hominin Presence in Southern Europe," Quaternary International 243:80-91:2011.
Graphics:
1. Anonymous map of "Oldowan Sites," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 28 October 2010.
2. Efe, PePe. "Geological Units of the Iberian Peninsula," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 11 March 2013, translated by Graeme Bartlett.
The earliest have been found in Gona, Ethiopia, located at the northern end of the East African rift valley in the Afar triangle where the Arabian, Somalian and main African plates are pulling away from each other. Olduvai Gorge, which gave its name to the technology, is at the southern end of the valley in modern Tanzania.
Gona tools have been dated to 2.6 million years ago. That’s just before the Gauss-Matuyama reversal in the Earth’s magnetic field at the beginning of the Pleistocene. Many had volcanic origins. Tool makers held a rock with one hand and struck it with another rock held by the other hand. The chips or flakes were the tool, not the diminished stone. Most had an edge on one side. They looked like choppers and scrappers.
The trachytic basalt cobbles were taken from a nearby stream, and carried elsewhere to be worked. The stone workers, usually called flint knappers, selected fine-grained rocks. The fact other rocks were available indicated they had spent time observing stones and remembering the ones with best qualities.
Technology is transportable. Gona’s techniques spread from Africa, where they were used until 1.7 million year ago. Although the above map only shows significant sites in Asia and Europe, Oldowan tools have been recorded in northern Spain after the industry faded from the Rift Valley. Sima del Elefante has artifacts made from chert, quartz, and limestone dated between 1.4 and 1.1 million years. Gran Dolina has quartzite tools from 800,000 years ago.
Both caves are in the Atapuerca formation less than 10 miles east of Burgos. The isolated limestone formation stood above waters running through the Bureba Pass pass between the Cantabrian mountains to the north and the Sistema Iberia abutting from the south during the Cenozoic. It’s the narrow yellow section toward the north on the map below.
The Oldowan quartzite probably came from terraces of the Arlanzón river that flows through Burgos to meet a tributary of the Duero. The Atapuerca chert formed in the later Miocene when silica grew into nodules within the limestone. Flint forms when the limestone is chalky. Limestone is a form of calcium carbonate.
The basalt of Gona and the quartzite and chert of Atapuerca contain silica dioxide (SiO2), the major component in glass and in sand. They break along clear planes with sharp edges, but those planes aren’t visible like they are with mica. Sileshi Semaw believed the ability to fracture them by striking signified a high level of skill and coordination.
Manufacturing techniques and their associated economies survived changes in biology and culture. The earliest bones associated with Oldowan tools were Australopithecus garhi. The modified rocks also have been found with Homo habilis, Homo ergaster, and Homo erectus.
The Gona tools were found along a tributary of the Awash river, upstream and a bit west of Hadar where Lucy, the oldest human ancestor, was found. The Australopithecus afarensis remains are 3.2 million years old. They haven’t been associated with tools.
At Gran Dolina the Oldowan technology was expanded to include chips of different sizes used for different purposes by Homo antecessor. José Bermúdez de Castro’s team believed the species was the immediate ancestor of Neanderthals. While it had the nasal area of the modern species, its jaws and teeth were like those of Homo erectus.
Innovation has two phases. First comes the invention of a technique, then the modification of that idea to fit new circumstances. Both involve a willingness to experiment, an ability to learn from experience, and an expectation of repeatability. Anyone can throw a rock at a boulder to break off a chip, but only a tool maker will watch the arc and aim another to change the outcome to fit a desired end.
Notes:
Bermúdez de Castro, J. M., et alia. "A Hominid from the Lower Pleistocene of Atapuerca, Spain: Possible Ancestor to Neandertals and Modern Humans," Science 276:1392-1395:1997.
Carbonell, Eudald, Paula García-Medrano, et alia. "The Earliest Acheulean Technology at Atapuerca (Burgos, Spain): Oldest Levels of the Galería Site (Gii Unit)," Quaternary International 353:170-194:2014.
Semaw, Sileshi. "The World’s Oldest Stone Artefacts from Gona, Ethiopia: Their Implications for Understanding Stone Technology and Patterns of Human Evolution Between 2.6-1.5 Million Years Ago," Journal of Archaeological Science 27:1197-1214:2000.
____, Jay Quade, et alia. "Paleoenvironments of the Earliest Stone Toolmakers, Gona, Ethiopia," Geological Society of America, Bulletin 116:1529-1544:2004.
Toro Moyano, Isidro, et alia. "The Archaic Stone Tool Industry from Barranco León and Fuente Nueva 3, (Orce, Spain): Evidence of the Earliest Hominin Presence in Southern Europe," Quaternary International 243:80-91:2011.
Graphics:
1. Anonymous map of "Oldowan Sites," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 28 October 2010.
2. Efe, PePe. "Geological Units of the Iberian Peninsula," uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, 11 March 2013, translated by Graeme Bartlett.
Tuesday, February 17, 2015
Spanish Geography
If one wants to understand the origins of Massachusetts Bay Colony, one looks at East Anglia on the eastern English coast. If one wants to understand the sources for the American south, one looks to the west of Bristol. It does no good to study the midlands.
Likewise, if one wants to understand the origins of Santa Cruz, one doesn’t bother with Madrid or Seville or Barcelona. One looks at Estremadura in Spain and Zacatecas in México. The first was home to Hernán Cortés, conqueror of the Aztecs in 1520. The other was founded by Cristóbal Oñate and two other Basques in the 1540s.
Today, Estremadura is divided into two provinces, Cáceres in the north, Badajoz to the south. The one includes the towns of Guadalupe and Trujillo. The other has Albuquerque, Herrera del Duque, and Talavera la Real.
The founders of Zacatecas also used familiar names. Francisco de Ibarra called the area Nueva Vizcaya, after one of the three modern Basque provinces, Biscay. The others are Álava and Gipuzkoa.
Spain sits on a peninsula surrounded by the Mediterranean on the east, the Atlantic on the west, the Bay of Biscay on the north, and the Straits of Gibralter on the south. It’s dominated by the westward sloping Meseta Central of Castile. Today, the plateau is ringed by the Sistema Ibérico to the northeast, the Cordillera Cantabrica to the northwest, and the Sistema Penibético of the Betic range to the southeast.
The Iberian mountains contain the headwaters of the west flowing rivers, the Duero, the Tagus and the Guadiana. The Ebro flows east. The Sistema Central range separates the Duero from the Tagus, and Estremadura from Castile and León to the north. The mountains continue into Portugal where Serra da Estrela defines the western boundary of the Estremaduran geographic province north of the Tagus.
Below the Tagus, Serra d’Ossa defines the southern part of the western boundary in Portugal. Sierra Moreno divides the Guadiana from the Guadalquivir and Estremadura from the lands controlled by the Moors in Spain.
Notes:
Bas de Jong, "Topographical map of Spain," Wikipedia Commons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)